Le 4 mai 2021, la plateforme Yahoo Questions/Réponses fermera. Elle est désormais accessible en mode lecture seule. Aucune modification ne sera apportée aux autres sites ou services Yahoo, ni à votre compte Yahoo. Vous trouverez plus d’informations sur l'arrêt de Yahoo Questions/Réponses et sur le téléchargement de vos données sur cette page d'aide.
What is with this 'Southern Ireland' business? Don't people know that the name of the state is?
of the state is the Republic of Ireland, also called Eire, and referred to as Ireland also, and that to differentiate between the Republic and Northern Ireland, people from Northern Ireland say they are from Northern Ireland?
It's almost 90 years since Ireland became a republic. You'd think people would catch on.
Rotifer, this happens A LOT on Yahoo Answers.
14 réponses
- QLv 5il y a 1 décennieRéponse favorite
Ignorance
There you go. From my experience, the majority that referred this country to 'Southern Ireland' were English.....and liked to piss people off by saying it when they discovered they were talking to an Irish person in a call centre. That and 'aren't you far from home?' was another that made me want to kill the phone.
There is no such thing as 'Southern Ireland' and never will be.
Source(s) : call centre experience dealing with customers from the UK. The Scots and Welch always got it right though :) - ?Lv 4il y a 4 ans
eire is 3 hundred miles long and approximately 220 Miles huge.each and all of the Mountains are in general on the Coasts.The Dublin and Wicklow Mountains, The MacGillycuddy Reeks in Kerry, The Donegal Hills, and the Mountains of Mourne in Antrim and Armagh.the midsection of the country is composed of Plains.There are 26 Counties interior the South of eire,and six Counties interior the united kingdom province of Northern eire.there's a inhabitants of four,0200,000 interior the Republic and a million,0500,000 interior the united kingdom Province of Northern eire. The Celts have been the 1st human beings to stay in eire and believed interior the Druidic Religeon of the Celts. then Viking Raiders got here and settled and after that the Normans got here under Richard De Clare Earl Of Pembroke Strongbow. Then the Normans have been finally to be time-honored because of the fact the English.In 1916 there become the Easter insurrection and then the conflict of Independence and then The Treaty of 1922 Splitting eire in 2 With the 6 Counties interior the North final area of the united kingdom and the 26 Counties forming the loose State , in Gaelic, Saorstat Eireann, whilst final area of the British Commonwealth.In 1939 whilst King Edward Married Mrs Simpson eire Refused to understand the recent King and left the Commonwealth and shaped the Republic of eire and made a clean shape. i could pass on advert infinitum all night .you will could swot up on Irish history in youre community Library or on the internet good success.
- RotiferLv 5il y a 1 décennie
I haven't heard anyone refer to it as Southern Ireland, I've only heard it referred to as Ireland, the Republic of Ireland, and Eire. But you're right to complain if they are doing that. I think most people in the UK know what to call the Republic of Ireland, couldn't speak for the media or anyone else.
- Guru HankLv 7il y a 6 ans
It is what people in the British Isles call that bit of Germany which the Germans call the 'Bundesland von Südirland'
- Anonymeil y a 1 décennie
With my family roots being in Strabane I understand the problem and agree there is a lot of ignorance about. I get round the problem by only ever using the terms "Northern Ireland" and "Eire".
Saves an awful lot of problems but don't expect the Americans to understand.
Ian
- Anonymeil y a 1 décennie
No, they most probably do not know the correct name of the state, the world is an exceedingly large place, why would everyone in the world be privy to this piece of information.
Particularly given the fact that the British media, American media, and others, regularly refer to the state as Southern Ireland or the South of Ireland when wishing to specify 'Not Northern Ireland'
Yes, quite true, this is an inaccuracy, but we cannot stop the media doing it, just as we cannot stop the media and politicians going on about 'Britain' when they mean United Kingdom, among other inaccuracies,
Southern Ireland, one of the former constituent countries of the United Kingdom which only exist for just over a year is hardly what people are referring to.. this was so long ago that most people outside of Ireland would not even be aware that the state ever existed. It is not taught about or even mentioned in schools outside of Ireland..
If someone referrs to Ireland as Southern Ireland, the intelligent thing to do would be to answer their question first, then politely point out the correct name of the state, instead of the patronising, abrupt and quite frankly rude way it is currently being bayoneted down unwitting user's throats.
Some answerers don't even bother to answer the question, and simply go on a rant about how Southern Ireland should not be used. Being Irish myself I do on my visits to this section find certain users incredibly uptight and must give potential visitors to our country a very bad impression indeed.
- Anonymeil y a 6 ans
southern ireland is the geographical name and the republic is the legal/political name
- Guillaume DLv 5il y a 1 décennie
You and I both answered yet another question about passports,and both of us got fired with thumbs down (I got 11 to be precise,and you 6 I think^^),because we mentioned this exact issue.I think that people use the logic that since there is a Northern Ireland,there has to be a Southern Ireland too,this is wrong of course.Could be worse I suppose,I met two yanks last summer who said to me that they would not be visiting ireland,because ''Isn't there a war over there?''
- greenorlaghLv 6il y a 1 décennie
You don't seem to know the name of the state either!!! What you mean it's 90 years since Ireland became a republic?
Ireland is an island. The name of the country you are talking about is the Republic of Ireland. You don't hear Northern Irish people refer to their country as Ireland. They don't have that right and neither do you - especially since the Republic no longer claimed the 6 counties under the Anglo Irish Accord.
You'd think you'd catch on. Thicko.
- Anonymeil y a 1 décennie
But after so many years of the troubles, it can take time for people to realise that Ireland is one island divided between two countries NI and Eire.
- Anonymeil y a 1 décennie
Sorry but I agree with the answerer above, Ireland's not a big place, there are a number of different names for the Island and the 2 countries on it...............If you really do feel compelled to correct someone could you not at least do it nicely!!!???